Sir James Bevan, chief executive of the Environment Agency, has called for a ban on all UK waste exports. His reasoning is that because the waste industry is corrupt, it is morally wrong to allow recyclable materials to be sent to other countries. However, before we look at the differing opinions on waste export and recycling, let’s first examine what has been happening with waste exports and why it has become such a controversial issue in recent years.
Exporting Waste and Corruption: Are They the Same Thing?
The issue of exporting waste has become a controversial issue in recent years due to the growing number of reports of how foreign recyclers have been treating the waste they have been receiving from the UK. It has been revealed that they are exporting contaminated waste, sending it to incinerators rather than recycling centres and, in some cases, it has even been seen that the waste has been dumped in countries like India.
As a result, some are calling for a complete ban on UK waste exports so that the problem of waste exports is solved once and for all. However, this argument is not as simple as it seems. As the number of reports of waste exports and possibly illegal activities increases, some are concluding that recycling is the same as waste exports and that a ban on waste exports will automatically put a stop to the illegal treatment of waste by foreign countries.
But is this conclusion well-founded? Or is it a way of justifying the UK’s materials economy, which is considered to be unsustainable?
Why Does the UK Produce So Much Waste?
The UK is one of the biggest producers of waste in the world. In its most recent annual report, the Environment Agency makes it clear that the UK needs to address the issue of its waste output. But it also makes it clear that it is actually the UK’s economy which creates the waste output in the first place.
The report goes on to say that the UK’s waste generation is “extremely dependent on economic activity”. Therefore, if the UK is to reduce its waste output, it will have to start with altering its economy so that it doesn’t produce so much waste in the first place.
The UK is one of the richest countries in the world. It also has one of the lowest birth rates, as well as one of the highest numbers of people living alone. It also has the most consumer-orientated economy.
All of these factors mean that a huge number of products are produced and sold every single day. However, because they are mass-produced, they are not of the highest quality. They may have a high price, but when we consider the number of products being produced and the time it takes for them to break down, we can clearly see that the UK’s economy is unsustainable.
Perhaps the most significant of all the UK’s economic problems is that, because of its high consumption, it has massive stockpiles of waste, which it continues to produce. This makes the UK’s economy one of the most wasteful in the world. One aspect of this problem is that the UK has one of the highest rates of household waste in the world.
What the Industry Is Saying
If we are to alter the UK’s economy so that it produces less waste, we must alter its entire attitude to waste. Until we do so, we will continue to consume, and produce, large amounts of waste. However, this process is extremely expensive, and one way of making it cheaper is to export the waste.
For example, it is far cheaper to transport waste to Asia or Africa than it is to recycle it in the UK. Therefore, in the short term, it is far more cost-effective to export the waste.
However, when we look at the long-term implications of exporting waste to foreign countries, we begin to see that this is not the best way to approach the problem of waste.
The trouble with the UK’s economy is that it is based on consumption. Therefore, the more we consume, the more waste we produce. Also, as products are produced cheaply, they are not as high-quality as they would be if they were made to last.
Therefore, the more we produce and consume, the more money we generate – but only for a short period of time. If we continue to produce things that have a single-use, we continue to create disposable waste.
This is why the UK economy is so dysfunctional, because it continually creates new things which are not of the highest quality, and the UK is continuing to create a huge amount of waste. Even if the UK doesn’t export its waste to other countries, it will still produce a high level of it.
What the UK Government Is Saying
The Environment Agency has said that the UK should ban all waste exports. However, the government has said that this is not a viable option. In its report, it says that if the UK were to ban waste exports, the country would have to replace the lost jobs and tax revenues with at least £2 billion.
According to the government, it doesn’t have the financial resources to fund such a replacement. Therefore, it is better to allow its economy to continue exporting waste and then use the money it makes to pay for waste treatment of the most toxic waste that is exported.
It seems strange, then, that the government is so keen to keep the UK’s economy going by allowing the export of waste. After all, this is the same government that says that it wants to reduce the amount of waste we produce.
Recycling has become an important issue in recent years, in part because of the levels of waste the UK is exporting to countries like India. It seems to be the majority view that the UK should stop exporting its waste.
However, recycling is not the same as waste export. The UK economy is entirely predicated on consumption and production. Therefore, no matter how much recycling we do, waste will continue to be produced.
This is why it seems that the debate about waste exports is far from over. The UK’s economy is still extremely wasteful, even if it recycles more. Therefore, we need to address the problems with our economy before we can move on to making recycling a more viable solution to the problem of waste.
If you want to contribute to the solution to the waste export problem, get a Chester skip hire from Enviro Skip Hire. Enviro Skip Hire is a family-run skip hire and aggregate company servicing Staffordshire. Check out our wide range of skip sizes and aggregates.